Underpayments in the medical billing world are like stealthy pickpockets. They quietly chip away at your revenue without making much noise. But over time, they can leave a sizable dent in your bottom line. For practices with 5-50 locations, where margins can already be thin, these small leaks can make a big difference. Identifying and recovering underpayments isn't just about keeping your practice afloat—it's about ensuring you're paid what you're owed.
What Is an Underpayment?
At its simplest, an underpayment occurs when a payer reimburses less than the agreed-upon rate for a service. The payer might shortchange you based on errors in the claim, misinterpretations of the contract, or a host of other reasons. Sometimes, it's an honest mistake—other times, it's due to systemic issues within payer processes.
Consider this scenario: your practice has a contract with Payer XYZ to be reimbursed $150 for each 99213 code billed. You receive a payment of $120 instead. That $30 difference is an underpayment. Multiply it by hundreds or thousands of claims over time, and you've got a revenue loss that could have supported new hires, technology upgrades, or simply more robust financial health.
Why Do Underpayments Happen?
Underpayments can stem from several sources. First and foremost are contract discrepancies. Payer contracts can be complex and open to interpretation. A single misinterpretation might lead a payer to reimburse less than they should.
Then there's the issue of outdated fee schedules or contractual terms not being updated in payer systems. Payers are notorious for delays in updating these critical components, leaving practices scrambling to reconcile payments that don't match what's expected.
Additionally, manual errors by payer staff during claims processing can result in underpayments. And let's not forget about the elephant in the room—automated systems that may not be perfectly synchronized with contract terms, leading to formulaic but incorrect payout amounts.
Identifying Underpayments
The first step in tackling underpayments is identifying them. This part of the process can be tedious, but it's necessary. Start with a thorough understanding of your payer contracts. Know them inside and out. This knowledge will form the backbone of your underpayment detection strategy.
Payment Posting and Reconciliation
When payments come in, they need to be meticulously posted and reconciled against the expected contracted rates. Your billing software should aid in this, but a sharp eye from your billing team is irreplaceable. Remember, software can only flag what it's programmed to recognize—human oversight is crucial.
Contractual Rate Tables
Maintain detailed, up-to-date contractual rate tables. These tables should reflect what you're supposed to be paid for each service. Use them as your baseline for comparison against incoming payments. This is not just for billing staff but for your entire revenue cycle team. Everyone should know what to look for.
Regular Audits
Performing regular audits of paid claims against your expected rates is non-negotiable. Set up a schedule—quarterly is a good start but tailoring it to your volume and payer mix is better. Anomalies can quickly become apparent when audits are systematic, and trends—whether they're payer-specific or service-specific—can be spotted and addressed.
Technology and Automation
Modern billing systems often come with tools designed to help automate some of this process. Utilize them! Automation can be configured to flag discrepancies between expected and received payments, offering a starting point for deeper investigation. But don't rely solely on technology. It's a tool, not a crutch.
Recovering Underpayments
Once underpayments are identified, the next step is recovery. This is where persistence pays off. Payers aren't always eager to adjust payments—they may need reminders, documentation, and sometimes a firm nudge.
Document Everything
Keep meticulous records of every communication with payers. When you submit a request for an adjustment, note the claim details, payer response timelines, and any follow-up required. Having a well-documented trail can be invaluable, especially if the underpayment needs to be escalated.
Leverage Payer Portals
Utilize payer portals to track progress on submitted adjustments. Portals can offer real-time updates on claim status, and they sometimes allow for direct communication with payer representatives. They're not perfect (and some are downright frustrating), but they're a necessary part of the toolkit.
Escalate When Necessary
If a payer is unresponsive or denies a justified adjustment, don't hesitate to escalate. Know the payer's escalation process and use it. Sometimes it takes multiple attempts and higher-level intervention to correct an underpayment issue. Persistence matters.
Engage in Negotiation
In cases where a payer disputes the adjustment request, be prepared to negotiate. This is where a thorough understanding of your contract comes back into play. Your ability to articulate exactly why the adjustment is warranted can make all the difference.
Building a Culture of Vigilance
Ultimately, combating underpayments is about building a culture of vigilance within your practice. Educate your team about the financial impact of these occurrences. Encourage them to take ownership of the reconciliation process and to feel empowered in addressing discrepancies.
As healthcare continues to evolve, so too will the challenges associated with payer reimbursement. Underpayments won't disappear overnight, but a systematic approach to identifying and recovering them can ensure your revenue integrity is sound. And that, in the end, is what keeps practices thriving—not just surviving.
Related Articles
