Underpayments are the ghost in the machine of medical billing. They slip through the cracks, often unnoticed, and quietly siphon revenue from practices. The reality is stark: most practices lose $200,000 or more annually to these underpayments. And it's happening more than practitioners would like to admit.
The Anatomy of an Underpayment
Underpayments are what happen when insurers reimburse less than the contracted rate. The most common culprits are coding errors, misinterpretations of fee schedules, or deliberate strategies by payers to delay full payment. Payers like to fly under the radar. They might pay 85% of a claim, betting you won't notice the missing 15%. Multiply that by thousands of claims, and the numbers become staggering.
Common Coding Errors
Let's be clear: coding is hard. Incorrect use of modifiers, outdated codes, or simple typos can lead to underpayments. For example, failing to append modifier 25 on an E/M service same-day as a procedure can result in a denial or reduced payment. Practices might be leaving 15% on the table with these kinds of mistakes.
Mischievous Fee Schedules
Payers are not always transparent about their fee schedules. Contracts might specify a payment rate that seems solid—until you notice it's based on a percentage of a year-old Medicare fee schedule. Suddenly, you're getting 20% less than expected. Insidious, right?
Payer Tactics: The Fine Art of Delays
Payers are in no rush to part with their money. A common tactic involves stalling payments through repeated requests for documentation. They know that every day a claim is outstanding, the chance that the practice will follow up diminishes. Payer portals are notorious for glitches—toss in long hold times, and it's like they’re daring you to give up.
The Credentialing Trap
Another trick up payers' sleeves involves credentialing. Delays in updating provider credentials can result in claims denied outright or paid at lower out-of-network rates. Practices must vigilantly track credentialing processes (and never trust that a payer will do it correctly without oversight).
Quantifying the Loss
Let's do some math. For a practice billing $5 million annually, losing even 5% to underpayments equates to $250,000. That's not small change. Many practices don't even realize this is happening, attributing lost revenue to bad luck or an off month. In reality, it’s precisely managed payer strategy.
Taking Control: Auditing for Success
Surviving in this environment means taking auditing seriously. Regular audits can unearth patterns of underpayments. If you find one, you'll likely discover more. Treat these audits like detective work—identify where money is slipping away and rectify it.
Tools and Tactics
Invest in software that flags potential underpayments automatically. Many billing systems allow for custom rule sets to alert when payments don't align with expected amounts. Set these alerts aggressively.
Also, leverage benchmark data. If a payer consistently reimburses significantly less than others, call them out. Use your data to question discrepancies, and demand clear explanations.
Payer Negotiation: Not Just for Contracts
Negotiating doesn’t stop at the contract stage. If a payer is consistently underpaying, it's time for a sit-down (or a virtual one). Bring your data, show them the losses, and push for adjustments. Practices often underestimate their power. Remember, payers need you to send clean claims for their success too.
Building a Culture of Diligence
Instill a culture of vigilance in your billing department. Set KPIs around payer compliance and underpayment recovery. Celebrate wins when underpayments are recouped. This keeps the team motivated and focused on the bottom line.
Looking Ahead: The Path to Better Revenue Recovery
Underpayments are a hidden epidemic with costly implications. Practices cannot afford to be passive. By understanding the tactics payers use and implementing proactive measures—like regular audits, vigilant coding, and relentless follow-ups—practices can reclaim lost revenue.
Looking forward, practices that embrace a culture of diligence and deploy smart auditing technology will be the ones that thrive. They will turn the tide on underpayments, ensuring financial health and sustainability in a world where every dollar counts.
Related Articles
