A payment variance report is the unsung hero in the realm of medical billing. It’s a critical tool for identifying those pesky underpayments that sap revenue from healthcare practices. Knowledge is power, and being able to systematically catch and correct payment discrepancies can mean the difference between financial health and hemorrhage for a practice.
Understanding Payment Variance Reports
A payment variance report compares the expected payments from insurers to the actual payments received. The expected payment is calculated based on the contracted rate with the payer. The variance, then, represents the difference — a vital data point for any revenue cycle management (RCM) team worth its salt.
Consider this scenario: Your practice has a contract with a major insurer stipulating $150 payment for a specific procedure. However, the insurer pays $120 instead. That $30 variance, though seemingly small, can accumulate if undetected across numerous claims, affecting the bottom line.
Steps to Create a Payment Variance Report
Contractual Awareness
First, know your contracts inside out. Without an in-depth understanding of the agreed-upon rates, constructing an accurate report is impossible. Most contracts specify payment terms down to the CPT code level. Missing out on these details is like trying to navigate without a map.
Data Collection
Gather data from your practice management system. You’ll need two main data sets: the contracted rates and the actual payment data. Ensure that this data is cleaned and organized — duplicates or errors can throw off your entire analysis.
Variance Calculation
Use spreadsheet software or specialized billing software to calculate the variance for each claim. Subtract the actual payment amount from the expected amount, and you'll get the variance.
For example, if you were expecting $200 and received $180 for a claim, the variance is $20. Flag these discrepancies for further review.
Analyzing the Variance Report
Identify Patterns
Look for patterns in your variance report. Are certain payers consistently underpaying? Are specific services prone to discrepancies? Identifying these trends is the first step toward corrective action.
Prioritize by Impact
Not all variances are created equal. Prioritize your investigation by impact. A $5 variance may not warrant immediate attention, but a consistent $50 discrepancy across multiple claims with the same payer certainly does. Prioritize fixes for variances that will most impact your revenue.
Root Cause Analysis
For problematic variances, delve into the details. Was it a coding error? Did the payer apply a different rate than specified in the contract? Understanding the root cause is crucial in preventing future issues. This might involve detailed claims audits or payer discussions.
Addressing Underpayments
Payer Engagement
Once underpayments are identified, reach out to the payer. Start with a detailed explanation of the variance, supported by contract specifics. Phone calls can be effective, provided you have the time (and patience) to endure the hold music. Consider dedicated payer reps or account managers for larger discrepancies.
Escalation Pathways
If initial contact doesn't resolve the issue, escalate. Insurers often have specific escalation pathways for disputed claims. Make sure your team is familiar with these processes and utilize them when necessary.
Regular Monitoring
Make payment variance analysis a regular part of your RCM process. Monthly reviews can keep you on top of potential revenue leaks before they become critical.
Automation and Software Tools
Leveraging Technology
Automation can take much of the tedium out of variance reporting. Consider RCM software that integrates directly with your practice management system. Such tools can automatically flag discrepancies and even suggest follow-up actions. Arrow, for instance, is an AI copilot that can assist in identifying these patterns, offering a more productive alternative to manual reviews.
Software Selection
When selecting software, prioritize functionality that aligns with your processes. Look for features like rule-based variance flagging, easy integration with your existing systems, and robust reporting capabilities. Avoid solutions with a steep learning curve that will slow down your team.
Common Pitfalls and Challenges
Misaligned Expectations
Sometimes, the issue lies in misaligned expectations. Ensure that both your billing team and payers have a common understanding of contractual obligations. This requires clear communication and sometimes renegotiation of terms.
Resistance to Change
There can be resistance—both from within the practice and from payers—to adopting new processes. Training and buy-in from all stakeholders are essential to overcoming these challenges.
Data Integrity
Inaccurate or incomplete data will sabotage your efforts. Regular data audits are non-negotiable. Ensure that all inputs into your variance report are current and accurate.
The Takeaway
Payment variance reports are not just a check-the-box activity; they are a strategic tool in the fight against underpayments. When done right, they offer a clear picture of where revenue is leaking and provide a roadmap to plug those gaps. Keep these tips in your toolkit, and transform your practice’s revenue cycle into a well-oiled machine.
Related Articles
