All Articles

How the No Surprises Act Changed the Economics of Medical Billing

The No Surprises Act created winners and losers. How it reshaped out-of-network strategies and dispute resolution.

The No Surprises Act created winners and losers. How it reshaped out-of-network strategies and dispute resolution.

The No Surprises Act created winners and losers. How it reshaped out-of-network strategies and dispute resolution.

The No Surprises Act has sent ripples through the world of medical billing, leaving some practices celebrating newfound clarity while others scramble to adjust. Signed into law to protect patients from unexpected charges, this legislation has reshaped out-of-network billing strategies and the dynamics of dispute resolution. Let's dissect the winners and losers in this new landscape — and how practices can adapt.

Who Wins Under the Act?

Patients are the obvious winners here. By eliminating surprise bills for emergency services and certain non-emergency situations, the Act significantly reduces out-of-pocket costs. They no longer face the dreaded sticker shock after a hospital visit. This protection also extends to ancillary services provided by out-of-network providers at in-network facilities. Gone are the days of a $2,000 out-of-pocket anesthesiology bill — at least, for those covered under the Act.

But there's another winner: in-network providers. The Act has tipped the scales in their favor by making out-of-network billing far more cumbersome. Patients are more likely to choose in-network facilities and practitioners to avoid the hassle of dealing with balance bills. For practices with ample insurance contracts, this is a golden opportunity to rake in more business.

The Losers: Out-of-Network Providers

The biggest losers? Out-of-network providers. For them, the No Surprises Act adds layers of complexity to an already challenging billing process. Key revenue streams are in jeopardy, especially when patients opt for in-network alternatives, even for high-demand specialties like radiology and anesthesiology.

While the Act makes it harder to balance bill patients, it doesn’t outlaw it entirely. Providers must now give patients advance notice and obtain consent to receive out-of-network care — a hurdle that often results in canceled appointments or the need for significant fee negotiations.

Reshaping Out-of-Network Strategies

Out-of-network providers can't afford to stand still. They need to pivot. Some are renegotiating contracts with payers to become in-network, while others are fine-tuning their patient engagement strategies.

Communication is key. Practices are investing in patient outreach — explaining the benefits of their services and why seeing an out-of-network provider might still make sense. In some cases, practices are restructuring their financial policies to offer more flexible payment plans, cushioning the blow of higher out-of-pocket costs.

Then there's technology. Practices are deploying more advanced billing systems and leveraging analytics to better understand payer trends and patient preferences. By integrating these insights, they can make smarter decisions about which services to market and how to price them competitively.

The New World of Dispute Resolution

Dispute resolution is another area where the No Surprises Act has stirred the pot. The Act introduces an independent dispute resolution (IDR) process that allows providers and payers to resolve payment disputes without involving the patient. But this system isn’t without its pitfalls.

The IDR process is time-consuming and can drain resources. It requires detailed documentation and a strategic approach to make a compelling case. But here's the kicker: the arbiter often leans towards an established metric known as the "qualifying payment amount" — usually the insurer's median in-network rate. This shifts the balance of power towards payers, forcing providers to be more strategic when entering disputes.

Navigating Payer Power Plays

Payers now have more leverage, and they're not afraid to use it. They're pushing back harder during negotiations, citing the IDR outcomes as precedent. Some are even dragging their feet on payments, waiting for providers to initiate disputes.

This requires a proactive approach from billing teams. They need to monitor payer behaviors closely — flagging delayed payments and patterns of denial. Maintaining meticulous records is no longer optional; it’s a necessity.

Engaging with payers has become a tactical game. Billing teams must prepare for longer wait times and repetitive requests for documentation. It's frustrating, but understanding each payer’s process can minimize roadblocks. Building relationships with payer reps can also grease the wheels, helping expedite resolutions.

What Practices Can Do Now

So, where does this leave medical practices? Those affected must rethink their strategies and workflows. Consider these steps:

  1. Evaluate Out-of-Network Services: Take a hard look at how out-of-network services fit into the overall business model. Are they still viable, or is it time to pivot to more in-network services?

  2. Enhance Patient Communication: Clear, upfront communication about costs and options is more important than ever. Patients should be informed and empowered in their decision-making process.

  3. Invest in Technology: Utilize billing and analytics technologies to streamline operations and gain insights into payer trends.

  4. Strengthen Documentation Practices: Comprehensive documentation can make or break cases in dispute resolutions. Tighten up these practices to avoid costly missteps.

  5. Foster Payer Relationships: Building a rapport with payer representatives can ease the dispute process and lead to faster payment resolutions.

By adapting to these new realities, practices can weather the changes brought about by the No Surprises Act. While it challenges traditional billing methods, it also offers an opportunity for those willing to evolve. In this altered economic landscape, the practices that choose innovation and adaptability will be the ones to thrive.

Upgrade to Arrow for more features

OpenRCM answers your billing questions. Arrow puts your A/R on autopilot, supercharging your billing team to do more.

  • Automate A/R follow-up

  • Resolve denials faster

  • Track real-time revenue

  • Collaborate with your team in one place

Arrow-CoreExchange

Try OpenRCM for free

Upgrade to Arrow for more features

OpenRCM answers your billing questions. Arrow puts your A/R on autopilot, supercharging your billing team to do more.

  • Automate A/R follow-up

  • Resolve denials faster

  • Track real-time revenue

  • Collaborate with your team in one place

Arrow-CoreExchange
Arrow-CoreExchange

Try OpenRCM for free

Upgrade to Arrow for more features

OpenRCM answers your billing questions. Arrow puts your A/R on autopilot, supercharging your billing team to do more.

  • Automate A/R follow-up

  • Resolve denials faster

  • Track real-time revenue

  • Collaborate with your team in one place

Arrow-CoreExchange
Arrow-CoreExchange

Upgrade to Arrow for more features

OpenRCM answers your billing questions. Arrow puts your A/R on autopilot, supercharging your billing team to do more.

  • Automate A/R follow-up

  • Resolve denials faster

  • Track real-time revenue

  • Collaborate with your team in one place

Arrow-CoreExchange
Arrow-CoreExchange